Wednesday 11 December 2013

'Absurd' double points rule overshadows some good intentions


A few days ago the F1 Strategy Group and the Formula One Commission agreed a number of changes to the regulations to be implemented for the 2014 and 2015 seasons.

From next season drivers will be able to choose their own numbers from #2 to #99 which will remain with them for the rest or the entirety of their careers. The champion driver will have the option of carrying #1. Nothing wrong with that, I think it’s a good idea. Much as Valentino Rossi has made the #46 his own in Moto GP or Wayne Gretzky made #99 his own in the world of Ice Hockey, it’ll be nice to have drivers associated with a permanent number.

Nigel Mansell was often associated with Red #5
Not least for those ardent fans who like to be up to date with merchandise of their favourite driver, they won’t have to worry too much about a driver changing teams or being higher in the Constructors championship as they’ll always now be associated with that number. So yes, good idea, well done Strategy Group.

To be implemented in 2015 is a budget cap, that budget has yet to be decided, but it is thought that it’ll be relatively high to start off with and reduce over a number of years. Whether the teams will agree with it or if it is able to be policed properly is very much open for debate but it is essential that Formula 1 brings the costs down.

You can see by the fact a top team like Lotus needs to take a driver with a budget (Pastor Maldonado) while missing out on Nico Hulkenberg who is once again stuck in the midfield because he doesn’t have any money behind him. This situation is unacceptable so a budget cap is the way forward.

However, with over a year before it is due to be introduced I’ll be interested to see if it goes any further beyond a nice idea. Teams with the spending power of Ferrari and Red Bull probably aren’t so keen to give up their advantage but for once I’d like to see the teams work together for the good of Formula 1 rather than their own self-interest to make it a more competitive and profitable environment for all the competitors and have a guarantee that each driver has been picked because of talent not how much sponsorship they can bring with them.

Finally, and I’ll try not to get carried away with how stupid an idea this is but to start from next season, the final race will be worth double points. Yes, that’s right in a reaction to Sebastian Vettel wrapping up the title with three races to go, it has been decided to jerk that knee to try and make sure the title fight goes down to the wire.

A budget cap with teams all competing on a level playing field is likely to create more competitive results over a season rather than saying ‘I know, let’s keep the title alive by wasting a driver’s entire seasons work so he can be beaten in the finale by a freak result by a driver who may well have been 49 points behind. That’s nearly two wins worth of points, but in the super finale all the 18 races beforehand doesn’t matter.

As Vettel has said, it’s ‘absurd’, and deserves to be written out of the rules before the season starts. As idea’s go it’ll just make a mockery of the results from the rest of the year, why should one race be worth more points? It’s artificial and quite frankly a bit condescending towards the fans of the sport.

Formula 1 and sports fans in general of course want a competitive year, but most don’t want it to be fake. I think they can just about cope with the DRS gimmick, it’s a bit Playstation, but passing was a problem, so they solved it, it doesn’t take away from overall tradition of the sport which this ruling does.

Formula 1 is about scoring the most points over the year with each event worth the same amount of points. If it goes down to the last race and someone wins it because of the double points, then they quite literally have won it because of the last race being worth more points, not because they fought to be within a wins worth of points that every other event gives out.

A driver with a 49 point lead going into the finale will quite rightly feel robbed if he then loses because of an incident or mechanical failure, and what with the new technical regulations a mechanical problem will be far more likely than in recent years.

This isn’t Formula 1, this is ridiculous and I truly hope they have a complete rethink before 2014 gets underway. Other than that, I am quite looking forward to seeing what numbers the top drivers choose.

all photo's taken from autosport.com

No comments:

Post a Comment